To Agree Or Not To Agree: Should Your Business Contract Include An Arbitration Clause?
ar•bi•tra•tion – noun: a method of dispute resolution involving one or more neutral third parties
The idea of including an arbitration clause frequently arises during contract negotiation. But should you agree? The best and worst thing about arbitration is the same thing: When it’s over, it’s over. That is because the chances of convincing a court to overturn an arbitration award are usually between slim and none. Whether that is a good thing or a bad thing depends on whether you won. If you lost, chances are you’re out of luck trying to overturn the award. On the other hand, if you won, then, arbitrations are the greatest thing since sliced bread.
In making the decision, consider the following questions.
Economical, Easier, Fair?: Pros and Cons
First, if a dispute arises, will you likely be in a favorable forum? One way to avoid being “home towned” is to agree to arbitration in a neutral location in front of an arbitrator who presumably will be neutral.
Second, if a dispute arises, will you likely benefit by a jury trial (assuming it is the type of issue that would be tried to a jury) or not? For example, if your company is a very large, well respected employer in the community where your case would be tried, perhaps your company would be better served by rolling the dice with a jury and whatever jury prejudice might be inherent in your panel. Conversely, if your company has taken a beating in the local press lately or is one of the typical targets for plaintiff lawyers, e.g. an insurance company, you may prefer even a bad arbitrator to a jury that might view your company as having two strikes against it when you walk into court.
Third, what are the expenses associated with arbitration versus litigation? Many clients simply assume, without any analysis, that litigation will be more expensive than arbitration, but that does not always prove to be true. When you’re making this analysis, be sure to consider whether discovery is permitted under the arbitration rules that will govern your dispute, travel costs and other expenses, including most importantly the fees that will be charged by the arbitrators (unlike judges, they don’t work for free) and any fees charged by an association that will be administering the arbitration (many associations, like the American Arbitration Association, charge a fee based on the amount of controversy in the dispute).
Fourth, if discovery is not permitted under the arbitration rules that will govern your dispute, will that be to your company’s advantage or not? With all its evils, discovery does help lawyers and their clients avoid “trial by ambush,” which may occur if you show up at an arbitration hearing without the benefit of knowing much about your opponent’s case or what your opponent’s witnesses will say. The answer to this question may depend on whether you think discovery may be necessary to prove your company’s case or not. For example, if your company likely will be the claimant, it may not need much discovery to prove its case and “trial by ambush” may be a strategic advantage. Conversely, if your company will likely be defending a claim and it will be difficult to do so without the benefit of some discovery of your opponent’s case, arbitration may put your company at a disadvantage.
Drafting Tips for the Clause
If you do decide to include an arbitration clause in a contract or other legal document, here are some drafting tips to consider:
- Select a location for the arbitration that is at least no more inconvenient to you than to your potential adversary.
- Before specifying what arbitration rules will govern the dispute (e.g. the American Arbitration Association or the Nebraska Uniform Arbitration Act), be sure to carefully research what discovery is allowed, what expenses must be paid and by whom (some rules provide that arbitrators can award attorney’s fees and expenses to the prevailing party), how the arbitrator(s) will be selected (e.g. by mutual agreement, from a pool of approved arbitrators, etc.) and what ability you will have to challenge an unfavorable award.
- If the arbitration rules leave open to negotiation such matters as limiting the scope and amount of discovery, whether the prevailing party is entitled to recover and other procedural matters, be sure to consider filling those “gaps” with attorney’s fees provisions best suited to your company.
- Finally, don’t overlook the possibility (especially if your company is likely to be defending a claim in the arbitration) of including limitations on the scope of damages that an arbitrator can award by, for example, excluding punitive damages and consequential damages such as lost profits.
Of course, like any legal agreement, you should not consent to an arbitration clause before fully exploring the pros and cons of such a clause with your legal counsel before binding your company to such a clause. Remember, when it’s over, it’s over.